• Billy the Puppet, tiny handmade tricycle not included (or yes included up to you)
• A bit of blackmail addressed to Amanda Young, written by Mark Hoffman
• Black robe with red lining, standard Jigsaw apprentice chic
• One big weird looking key on a simple chain. It's for unlocking the shotgun collar, and is completely useless
• Pig mask. Made of latex. Has lanky black fake hair coming off of it. Looks yuck

Of all of these she'd probably like the robe or the key the most and would truly truly hate to get the puppet :) just so you know